Smoked Prime Rib with Herb Butter Bath
Menu
Together Doug Scheiding and his wife, Jennifer Talley, make up the Rogue Cookers Competition BBQ team. Doug and Jennifer cook exclusively on Traeger Pellet Grills. Head Country rubs and sauces have been a part of the Rogue Cookers arsenal since day one of their work as competitive cookers. Rogue Cookers won the Houston Rodeo World Championship (HLSR) in 2015, a 2nd and 4th Place in Brisket at the San Antonio Rodeo, and first place in Cook’s Choice Category at the Jack Daniel’s International Invitational, all using Head Country sauces, seasonings, and marinade. Doug is a Traeger BBQ Pro, a Head Country Brand Ambassador, and the Texas Embedded Correspondent to The BBQ Central Show.
1 tritip (approximately 3-4 lbs)
Head Country All-Purpose Marinade
Head Country Championship Seasoning, Original
Head Country Championship Seasoning, High Plains Heat
2 C. Head Country Bar-B-Q Sauce, Apple Habanero
1 C. Head Country Bar-B-Q Sauce, Sweet & Sticky
6-8 oz. cooking liquid leftover from brisket cook (beef broth works, too)
Apple juice for spritzing (Doug likes Martinelli’s)
Hardwood recommendation: Oak or hickory
325 degrees F
6 hours
“Burnt ends made from brisket or pork belly are wonderful nuggets of fatty deliciousness. However, I can personally only handle a few of them as they are so rich. This recipe is a great lean beef alternative and is a quicker cook than brisket.” —Doug
Preheat grill to 325 degrees F.
While the grill preheats, trim the fat cap off the bottom of the tri tip. Then, flip the tri tip over and trim all the silver skin off the top.
Look closely at the grain on the top. Use your knuckle to make what I like to call the Knuckle Notch (or use a knife to score) about a quarter of an inch deep down the middle, separating where the grains meet from the left and right side. Usually, there is a line of fat here as well. Doing this will help you be able to tell the direction of the grain, and where it changes, when slicing the tri-tip after smoking.
Put tri tip on the grill. Spritz every 30-45 minutes with apple juice. Cook to an internal temperature of 198-200 degrees F, like a brisket. This will take about 4 hours, depending on the weight of the tri-tip. Remove tri tip from the grill.
Increase the cook temp on your grill to 375 degrees F.
Combine 16 oz. (2 C.) of Head Country Bar-B-Q Sauce in Apple Habanero, 8 oz. (1 C.) of the Sweet & Sticky flavor, and 8 oz. of brisket juice (beef bouillon broth) in a bowl. Heat on the grill or microwave to lukewarm. Pour sauce mixture into a loaf pan (4×6”) for a single tri-tip, or a half pan (10×12”) for multiple tri-tips.
After the tri-tip has cooled some, cut against the grain (use your Knuckle Notch for guidance) into cubes, about ¾-1” pieces. Place the cubed meat into the pan with the sauce mixture.
Place the pan on the grill. You’ll notice the sauce mixture will begin to boil slightly around the edges. Cooking at this high of a temperature will help reduce the sauce over the next 1.5 hours, thickening and intensifying the flavor.
After the sauce has thickened, get the toothpicks out and enjoy!
